Truth to Power: Andrew Bacevich

By: BJ Lawson

After the turmoil over the past week, and looking towards the Senate’s likely vote on the Paulson plan on Wednesday, US Army Colonel Andrew Bacevich provides some excellent food for thought in his interview with Bill Moyers:

BILL MOYERS: It’s been a long time since I’ve read a book in which I highlighted practically every third sentence. So, it took me a while to read, what is in fact, a rather short book. You began with a quote from the Bible, the Book of Second Kings, chapter 20, verse one. “Set thine house in order.” How come that admonition?

ANDREW BACEVICH: Well, I’ve been troubled by the course of U.S. foreign policy for a long, long time. And I wrote the book in order to sort out my own thinking about where our basic problems lay. And I really reached the conclusion that our biggest problems are within.

I think there’s a tendency on the part of policy makers and probably a tendency on the part of many Americans to think that the problems we face are problems that are out there somewhere, beyond our borders. And that if we can fix those problems, then we’ll be able to continue the American way of life as it has long existed. I think it’s fundamentally wrong. Our major problems are at home.

BILL MOYERS: So, this is a version of “Physician, heal thyself?”

ANDREW BACEVICH: Well, yes, “Physician, heal thyself,” and you begin healing yourself by looking at yourself in the mirror and seeing yourself as you really are.

BILL MOYERS: Here is one of those neon sentences. Quote, “The pursuit of freedom, as defined in an age of consumerism, has induced a condition of dependence on imported goods, on imported oil, and on credit. The chief desire of the American people,” you write, “is that nothing should disrupt their access to these goods, that oil, and that credit. The chief aim of the U.S. government is to satisfy that desire, which it does in part of through the distribution of largesse here at home, and in part through the pursuit of imperial ambitions abroad.” In other words, you’re saying that our foreign policy is the result of a dependence on consumer goods and credit.

ANDREW BACEVICH: Our foreign policy is not something simply concocted by people in Washington D.C. and imposed on us. Our foreign policy is something that is concocted in Washington D.C., but it reflects the perceptions of our political elite about what we want, we the people want. And what we want, by and large - I mean, one could point to many individual exceptions - but, what we want, by and large is, we want this continuing flow of very cheap consumer goods.

We want to be able to pump gas into our cars regardless of how big they may happen to be, in order to be able to drive wherever we want to be able to drive. And we want to be able to do these things without having to think about whether or not the book’s balanced at the end of the month, or the end of the fiscal year. And therefore, we want this unending line of credit.

The video and transcript of the entire interview are available here. Are we ready to be the change we wish to see in the world?

3 Responses to “Truth to Power: Andrew Bacevich”

  1. Victor Pillow Says:

    I think a large portion of US citizens have been wrong for our entire existence. Thomas Jefferson and John Adams were the only ones who kept us out of war with France just after we became a country, despite the intent of many Americans. I wonder if we would have survived that war intact as we are today. Those two men may be our saviors as a nation. Which men will save us today from the fanatical, reptile like aggressive hankerings of those who seek war? Imagine how glorious and worldly respected our nation would be if after WW2 we had become a nation of peace and trade instead of a nation of aggression, interference, and war.
    Victor Lee Pillow (Iraq Vet)

  2. Mike Vasovski Says:

    Andrew Bacevich is a remarkable person. Incredibly intelligent, articulate and a gifted speaker. There are several lectures and interviews of and by him on line, all worth the time. I am 1/2 through his most recent book and it likewise is a must read for us.

  3. Sean O'Donnell Says:

    As a Naval Academy grad, I particularly enjoy and appreciate Bacevich’es intellectually honest and critical eye. Not a typical trait for an ‘Academy grad”. I am definately a fan of this guy and recommend his books.

    I do have issue with how he suggests US government is responding to citizens’ lust for consumption. Unless I’m misreading his work, he suggests the governmet is responding to our feelings of entitlement and our demands of not accepting a lower standard of living.

    It may be splitting hairs, but I would argue our consumption binge has been A RESULT of numerous government interventions on behalf of our government’s true constituency: the banking elite.

Leave a Reply